Paper or Plastic?

Neither. Try scan-and-go, a digital wallet, or buying inside an AI chat.

Turns out checkout is a lot more complicated than “paper or plastic.” Five of our six stories this month revolve around it. We cover a new survey on how shoppers like to check out, why some retailers are pulling back on self-checkout (SCO), Google’s plans to expand its digital wallet, Newegg selling through Google’s artificial intelligence (AI) shopping tools, and a new $699 annual fee from payment processor Global Payments. We also follow up on last month’s freezer hacks in Europe, now that U.S. agencies are warning grocers here in the states. Let’s get into it.

What Shoppers Want From Checkout

Cambridge Retail Advisors (CRA) asked 500 U.S. shoppers which checkout options they’d choose over a traditional staffed lane. Scan-as-you-shop came out on top at 51.2%, with AI self-checkout close behind at 49.4% and AI-assisted staffed checkout at 45.6%. Shoppers’ answers also changed depending on the trip. For baskets under five items, 64.2% preferred self-checkout, but only 23% did for high-value purchases like electronics or jewelry. CRA’s advice is to understand the trips customers are making before picking technology, rather than offering every checkout path under the sun.

Kitestring’s Take: Same shopper, different trip, different answer. That’s a connected commerce problem. A shopper’s cart, loyalty status, promotions, and payment preferences should follow them across the app, the aisle, and the lane, and every path has to behave the same way at the register. Most retailers can’t do that today, because every new checkout option has been bolted onto the point of sale (POS) as a separate integration. Before adding scan-and-go, AI self-checkout, or assisted checkout, ask whether your POS architecture can support them on one transaction engine. Wegmans shut down its SCAN app in 2022, citing losses. Sam’s Club kept going and added computer vision at the exit. The gap between those outcomes is usually architecture and controls, not the front-end idea.

Fee Fi Fo Fum

Global Payments is trying to raise prices even as analysts warn that its market is getting more competitive. The processor plans to add a new $699 annual fee for merchant clients starting in December, according to a merchant cost consultant who shared part of the company’s letter on LinkedIn. The letter points to government and industry regulations as the reason. Analysts at TD Cowen and Baird say newer fintechs are adding pricing pressure across payments, and analysts at William Blair questioned whether Global Payments’ technology can keep up.

Expert POV from Tim Webb: A surprise $699 annual fee is a symptom, not the problem. The payments industry is getting more competitive, and as processors deal with their own pressures (debt, mergers, private equity ownership, and a tough market), retailers end up footing the bill. The real problem is processor lock-in. Every retailer should be asking one question. If my processor raised my fees tomorrow, could I leave? If switching processors means major changes to your legacy POS, assuming you even have that option, your processor sets the price and you pay it. To get leverage back, retailers need payment architectures that are processor-agnostic, ideally with payment orchestration and more than one acquirer. That turns a price increase into a negotiation, not a hostage situation. More of these surprises are coming. Don’t wait for the next one. Architect for leverage now.

Please Wait for Assistance

SCO is losing ground with some retailers. A Toast survey of 340 small and midsize retail operators found about 36% used self-checkout this year, down from 43% in 2025. An ECR Retail Loss report found grocery stores saw an average 22% jump in merchandise losses in the year after installing SCO lanes, from both theft and honest scanning mistakes. Dollar General pulled self-checkout from about 12,000 stores in 2024. Still, 75% of operators plan to increase tech spending in the next year, and one expert expects a hybrid future with self-service for small baskets, staffed lanes for bigger or more complicated trips, and more tech helping employees catch errors.

Joint Take from Vicente Yañez and Michael Leister: Is self-checkout dying? We don’t think so. The problem isn’t self-checkout itself. It’s how it’s been implemented and managed. SCO wasn’t meant to be a one size fits all solution, and it has found its niche as a convenient alternative. Making it work takes the right hardware, software, loss prevention technology, and operational processes. The biggest improvements, like computer vision that reduces theft and friction, come from the POS platform, not the kiosk. Loyalty-based checkout, mobile baskets, buy online, pick up in store (BOPIS), and agentic commerce have followed the same path. None of them replace the cashier. They expand the POS to fit more shopper preferences. Rather than abandoning self-checkout, retailers should ask whether they’ve set it up to succeed.

Third Time’s the Checkout

Newegg has added Universal Commerce Protocol (UCP), an open agentic commerce standard backed by Google. U.S. shoppers can now buy eligible Newegg products directly inside AI Mode in Google Search and the Gemini app without leaving the conversation. Newegg stays the merchant of record on every order. This builds on Newegg’s earlier AI work. It was among the first retailers to offer checkout inside Perplexity conversations, and in June it launched a ChatGPT app with live pricing, inventory, and deals. Chief Information Officer (CIO) Montaque Hou says Newegg wants to be ready to answer wherever someone asks an AI what to buy.

Expert Opinion from Justin Clark: On its own, the Google integration is nice. But the surprising part is that it’s Newegg’s third AI integration, after Perplexity and ChatGPT. They’ve built a repeatable playbook for showing up wherever someone asks an AI what to buy, and they run it again each time a new platform opens the door. What I really like is who stays in control. On Google, Newegg stays the merchant of record while Google Pay handles payment, and its ChatGPT app hands shoppers back to Newegg.com to check out. Newegg still owns the sale, the fulfillment, and the customer support. Compare that to TikTok’s one-click checkout, where the entire shopping journey, plus the customer data that comes with it, can live completely inside someone else’s app. Newegg proves you don’t have to give that up to meet customers where they already are. The takeaway isn’t “go add a chatbot to your site.” It’s “build your catalog and checkout systems so they can plug into a new AI platform quickly, instead of starting over every time.” Newegg has done this three times, and it sounds like much of the underlying plumbing gets reused each time.

Not Your Parents’ Wallet 

Google wants its digital wallet to do a lot more than hold cards. Stavan Parikh, Google’s Vice President and General Manager of Payments, says the wallet should become a home for receipts, online order tracking, refunds, and merchant offers. He sees a big opportunity in physical stores, where most shopping still happens and digital wallets haven’t done much beyond payment. “We’re really just kind of scaling the wallet for end-to-end commercial journeys,” Parikh said. Google is also preparing the wallet for agentic commerce, where AI agents shop on a person’s behalf using limited payment credentials through Gemini and Google Pay.

Jason Todd’s POV: This is an interesting evolution of the digital wallet, and potentially a pretty important step toward a real loyalty ecosystem. Connecting purchases, preferences, offers, and the broader shopping experience starts to create something much more valuable than a collection of loyalty cards. The trick is making all of this feel like a natural part of the experience without crossing the fine line into feeling intrusive. Get that balance right, and the possibilities get pretty interesting, particularly as agentic commerce starts to enter the picture.

Freezer Burn, Part Two

Last month, we covered the hackers who turned French supermarket freezers into ovens. Now the U.S. government is warning grocers it could happen here. On Nov. 5, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), and the departments of Health and Human Services, Agriculture, and Transportation issued a joint bulletin on ongoing threats to industrial refrigeration systems, after the attacks spread from France to several other European countries. The agencies are urging operators to pull controllers off the public internet, separate operational technology (OT) devices from business networks, change default passwords, add multifactor authentication, patch firmware, and retire end-of-life devices.

Our Take: Last month, this was a European problem. Now five federal agencies are telling U.S. grocers to assume they could be next. Every connected device in the store, from freezer controllers to shelf labels to payment terminals, is part of the attack surface, and many are managed by facilities teams or vendors outside IT’s day-to-day view. The government’s recommendations are a solid starting point, but a checklist only works when someone is responsible for following it. Those tech debt time bombs we warned about in October are still ticking.

Thanks for Reading!

This month, shoppers said they want different checkout options depending on what they’re buying, retailers learned that self-checkout works best when it’s set up and managed well, and Google and Newegg moved more of the buying process into wallets and AI tools. Behind all of it are the systems retailers depend on, from the processors that set their fees to the connected devices running in their stores. When those systems are flexible, up to date, and under your control, adding the next checkout option gets a lot easier. From all of us at Kitestring, Happy Thanksgiving. We’ll be back in December with more.

Enjoyed this issue? Forward it to a colleague and share the insights!